Important information

The court process for serious criminal cases can at times be confusing and difficult to follow.

You can access information about the various stages of the court process via a dedicated section on this website here.

The prosecution of Mr Gargasoulas

Update: November 13, 2018

On November 13, 2018, a jury convicted Mr Gargasoulas of six charges of murder and 27 charges of reckless conduct endangering life.

He was remanded in custody and a plea hearing has been listed to run for three days from 29 to 31 January 2019.

Please note: All persons affected by the Bourke Street offending are able to make a victim impact statement. Please click here for more information.

Update: October 29, 2018

At a hearing in the Supreme Court on October 29, a jury found Mr Gargasoulas fit to stand trial. A trial has been set to begin on Wednesday , November 7 2018 and will run for approximately four weeks.

Update: July 4, 2018

At a hearing in the Supreme Court on July 4, 2018, a new date was set for a further fitness investigation to determine if Mr Gargasoulas is fit to stand trial. This will take place on October 12, 2018.

Depending on the outcome of this hearing, there may be a trial or special hearing from November 5, 2018.

Update: June 22, 2018

The jury was discharged on the morning of June 22 after failing to reach a verdict on Mr Gargasoulas’ fitness to stand trial.

The matter has been adjourned to July 4, 2018.

Update: May 22, 2018

The most recent stage in the prosecution of Mr Gargasoulas was a further mention hearing, which took place in the Supreme Court on May 21, 2018.

At this hearing, the Court heard Mr Gargasoulas had been assessed by four mental health experts, who all diagnosed him with a form of mental illness.

The Prosecution lawyers informed the Court that there are opposing views about whether Mr Gargasoulas is currently fit to stand trial.

The Court decided that a fitness investigation, where a jury would decide if the accused is fit to stand trial, would need to take place. A date for this hearing in the Supreme Court was set for June 12, 2018.

Update: March 20, 2018

The most recent stage in the prosecution of Mr Gargasoulas
was a further mention hearing, which took place in the Supreme Court on March 1, 2018.

At this hearing, the Court was advised by Defence and Prosecution lawyers of the progress of mental health experts in assessing whether or not the accused is fit to stand trial.

The Court has listed this matter for further mention on May 21, 2018, at 9.30am.  At this time the Court will decide whether or not there needs to be a fitness investigation, where a jury would decide if the accused is fit to stand trial.  If a fitness investigation is required this will commence in court on June 12, 2018.

The Prosecution requires the reports from the mental health experts before reaching a view as to whether or not the accused is fit to stand trial. These reports will only be available to the Prosecution lawyers from mid to late May, 2018.

A different court process applies in Mental Impairment cases, and information on this process is available on this website here.

Previous updates:

At a hearing in the Melbourne Magistrates’ Court on December 15, Mr Gargasoulas (the accused) decided not to proceed with a contested Committal Hearing in the Magistrates’ Court. As a result the case will now be conducted in the Supreme Court.

A Directions Hearing was held in the Supreme Court on Monday, December 18. At this hearing, lawyers for the accused informed the Supreme Court they had engaged a psychologist and a psychiatrist to assess whether their client was fit to stand trial and if he has the defence of mental impairment available to him. They said they had received a report from the psychologist and were waiting on the report from the psychiatrist.

Lawyers for the accused confirmed they would raise the issue of mental impairment and fitness to plead. The prosecution is in the process of engaging its own experts to have the accused assessed to determine the future conduct of the case.

The case was adjourned with a further hearing to take place in the Supreme Court on Thursday, March 1, 2018.

Witnesses please note: Witnesses are not required to attend court in the foreseeable future and if you are required, you will be informed well in advance by Victoria Police or the OPP.

The OPP has produced a guide called Prosecuting Mental Impairment Matters that explains the court process where mentally ill or cognitively impaired people are prosecuted for serious crimes.

Key dates so far

  • 23 January 2017 – alleged offender charged and Magistrates Court filing hearing
  • 17 February 2017 – Supreme Court mention (at the invitation of the court, to advise the court of the progress of the matter)
  • 15 June 2017 – Supreme Court mention (as above)
  • 1 August 2017 – Special Mention – Magistrates’ Court (to check on the progress of the brief of evidence)
  • 20 October 2017 – brief service (on time)
  • 27 November 2017 – further Supreme Court mention (to check on the progress of the defence obtaining reports about the questions of fitness to plead and the defence of mental impairment)
  • 4 December 2017 (as above)
  • 15 December 2017 – Magistrates' Court Committal Mention
  • 18 December 2017 – Supreme Court Direction's Hearing
  • 1 March 2018 – Supreme Court Mention Hearing

More information for witnesses

The OPP has sent out a letter to witnesses, victims, and bereaved family members directly involved in this matter, which contains information on the prosecution of Mr Gargasoulas.

An abridged version of this letter can be accessed here.